Halloween is one of the most magical times of the year for kids, costumes, candy, decorations, and a little bit of spooky fun! If you’re looking for a screen-free, super easy activity to get kids talking, laughing, and using their imagination, Halloween “Would You Rather” questions are perfect.
These questions are simple, silly, and can spark conversations at home, in the classroom, or even while waiting on the trick-or-treat trail. And the best part? We’ve created a FREE printable Halloween “Would You Rather” sheet just for you! 👻
🕸️ Why Kids Love “Would You Rather”
“Would You Rather” questions encourage kids to:
- Use their imagination
- Make choices and explain their reasoning
- Laugh and connect with family and friends
Halloween makes these questions even more fun with silly, spooky, and candy-filled themes.
🧛 How to Play
- Download and print the free Halloween “Would You Rather” sheet below.
- Read the questions aloud to your kids.
- Let them pick their answer and explain why.
- For extra fun, encourage them to come up with their own Halloween-themed questions!
🎃 10 Halloween “Would You Rather” Question Ideas by Age
Ages 2–5
- Would you rather wear a pumpkin hat or a ghost hat?
- Would you rather eat chocolate or gummy worms?
- Would you rather be a friendly witch or a friendly ghost?
- Would you rather have a cat’s tail or a bunny’s ears for Halloween?
- Would you rather ride a broomstick or a pumpkin carriage?
- Would you rather have candy in your shoes or in your pockets?
- Would you rather make a big pumpkin or a big spider web?
- Would you rather see a dancing skeleton or a singing vampire?
- Would you rather have a tiny ghost follow you or a tiny bat?
- Would you rather have a glowing pumpkin or a glowing hat?
Ages 5–7
- Would you rather be invisible for one night or fly for one night?
- Would you rather eat only candy corn or only caramel apples for a week?
- Would you rather have a friendly monster as a pet or a magical pumpkin?
- Would you rather be a witch or a vampire for Halloween?
- Would you rather explore a haunted house or a spooky forest?
- Would you rather have glowing shoes or a glowing cape?
- Would you rather ride a broomstick with your best friend or a ghost?
- Would you rather tell a scary story or hear a scary story?
- Would you rather make a potion or carve a pumpkin?
- Would you rather dance with zombies or sing with vampires?
Ages 7–10
- Would you rather live in a haunted castle or a pumpkin village?
- Would you rather be able to talk to ghosts or talk to black cats?
- Would you rather create a candy machine or a costume machine?
- Would you rather spend Halloween in space or under the sea?
- Would you rather ride a dragon or a giant bat?
- Would you rather have magical powers for one night or unlimited candy?
- Would you rather solve a spooky mystery or find a treasure in a haunted house?
- Would you rather dress as a zombie or a superhero for Halloween?
- Would you rather watch a scary movie or read a spooky book?
- Would you rather have a glowing pumpkin or a floating candle?
🎁 Free Printable Halloween “Would You Rather”
We’ve made this activity super easy for families, teachers, and caregivers. The free printable is a single sheet for the youngest in the house, if you are looking for other age groups with all the questions organized by age group, check out our ETSY shop to download your instantly!
Click on your favorite to shop and download INSTANTLY!
FREE PRINTABLE
🍂 Final ThoughtS
Halloween is about fun, imagination, and making magical memories. This “Would You Rather” activity is a simple, joyful way to spark conversation, laughter, and creativity with your kids. Pair it with hot cocoa, cozy blankets, and your favorite spooky tunes for a Halloween to remember!
✨ Don’t forget to share your kids’ funniest answers on Instagram @PrintasticKiddos. We love seeing the laughs!
